data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5c10b/5c10ba6e765e85b3e95be6b013266726a5792456" alt=""
The Detroit Free Press: "... the climax of the novel is a huge disappointment."
The Baltimore Sun: "... skips clumsily from perspective to perspective. It wallows in the pathos of war and death. [...] His accounts of the fighting leave no Civil War battle cliche unturned.